Previewed by: Christian Nutt. "...[T]he aim of a game like Pirates of the Caribbean is to immerse the player, not through its narrative, but through its freedom." [Xbox]

Reviewed by: Staff, [7.5/10]. "This game could have been great, but instead fell a little short." [Xbox] (July 24, 2003)

Reviewed by: Tim McConnaughy, [65/100]. "I've never seen a better game more tragically hamstrung by bugs and errors." [Xbox] (July 12, 2003)